The answer
Here’s what actually matters.
You can only compare two proposals fairly after you normalize the scope. First line up quantities, products/allowances, preparation, exclusions, professional responsibilities and completion boundary; then compare price.
Why totals alone mislead
A lower proposal may simply include less demolition, preparation, restoration or documentation. A higher proposal may include more work—or may just cost more. The scope tells you which.
Put these side by side
- quantities/areas
- materials/products/allowances
- demolition/preparation
- installation labor
- permits/trade responsibilities
- restoration/cleanup
- warranty/closeout
Then compare the risk
- what remains unknown
- what can become an extra
- how changes are approved
- what is excluded
Bottom line
Compare the same job before you compare the price.