The answer
Here’s what actually matters.
Choose cleanup when the basic layout works and the problem is overgrowth, weeds, debris, tired mulch or neglected maintenance. Choose redesign when the layout itself is the problem—wrong plants, poor use of space, drainage, privacy, irrigation, circulation or maintenance burden.
Florida licensing boundary
Who must handle the regulated work.
Ordinary landscape cleanup and planting are different from regulated utility work. Florida DBPR says compensated irrigation installation that requires connecting lines to potable water needs a licensed contractor, while installing or repairing an irrigation system that already has a backflow preventer connected to the potable supply is listed differently. Any electrical, plumbing or other regulated portion of a landscape project must go to the appropriately licensed trade.
Florida DBPR: what requires a license ↗ · Verify a Florida license ↗
| Factor | Cleanup / refresh | Redesign |
|---|---|---|
| Main goal | Restore what is already there | Change how the landscape functions or looks |
| Planting layout | Mostly stays | Changes materially |
| Removal | Selective | May be extensive |
| Design decisions | Limited | More important |
| Irrigation/drainage | Usually minor adjustments | May require rethinking zones/drainage |
| Best fit | Neglected but basically functional yard | Yard that does not work for the property or owner |
Choose Cleanup / refresh when...
- you like the basic layout
- most plants are worth keeping
- you mainly need pruning, cleanup, mulch or isolated replacement
Choose Redesign when...
- plants are wrong for sun/water/space
- privacy, drainage or circulation is poor
- you want to reduce maintenance or change how the yard is used
The part people miss
A redesign does not have to mean removing everything. Often the best plan keeps healthy mature elements and changes only what is not working.
Bottom line
Choose cleanup when the basic layout works and the problem is overgrowth, weeds, debris, tired mulch or neglected maintenance. Choose redesign when the layout itself is the problem—wrong plants, poor use of space, drainage, privacy, irrigation, circulation or maintenance burden.
Sources & further reading
These resources support the specific points noted below. They do not endorse OttoServ or verify a particular project.
- UF/IFAS: Florida-Friendly Landscaping principles ↗Landscape choices should reflect the site and ongoing care.